Dog walking & training · Heywood, Rochdale, Middleton & Bury

Blog · Harnesses

Harness for the lead.
Collar for the tag.

Harness or Collar for Walking Your Dog? A Dog Walker’s Honest Answer

For most dogs, clip the lead to a well-fitted harness and keep a flat collar on for the ID tag, because UK law asks for a collar in public. Here’s why, and which dogs it changes for.

By James Gonzo · · 7 min read

Start reading

The short answer

For most dogs on most walks, clip the lead to a well-fitted harness and keep a flat collar on with an ID tag. The harness takes the pull off the neck. The collar is there because UK law says your dog has to wear one with your details on it in public.

That’s the short version. Below is why, what the research actually found, and the dogs where the answer changes.

Some links in this post are affiliate links. If you buy through one, The Dog Geezer may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, The Dog Geezer earns from qualifying purchases.

This isn’t vet advice. If your dog has a neck, back or breathing problem, check with your vet first.

The short answer for harness or collar for walking: use both

  • Harness for the lead. Kinder on the neck if your dog pulls or lunges.
  • Collar for the tag. It’s the law in public places.
  • Fit both properly. A loose harness or collar is how dogs slip out near roads.

Dogs Trust puts it plainly: to comply with the law in public spaces, your dog “also wears a dog collar, with an identity tag attached to it, even if you are walking them in their harness.”

What UK vets and charities say

The big UK charities lean the same way.

  • PDSA: recommends a harness for dogs that pull, to “help prevent them from hurting their neck”. It also says not to use anything painful or that restricts movement, such as a choke collar.
  • Dogs Trust: harnesses are “a useful way to reduce the risk of neck injury”. They warn against harnesses that “cross directly in front of the shoulders preventing natural movement”.
  • Royal Kennel Club: for flat-faced dogs with breathing problems, it suggests “using a harness instead of a collar to avoid putting pressure on their airway”.
  • Battersea: “A flat collar is a simple, safe choice for most dogs.” So collars aren’t the enemy. It’s what happens to the neck when a dog hits the end of the lead.

What the research says (in plain words)

  • Collars and pulling. A 2020 study in the Veterinary Record tested seven collars and a slip lead on a model neck, not real dogs. Pressure on the neck ranged from 83 to 832 kPa, and the authors said no single collar kept the pressure low enough to reduce the risk of injury when pulling.
  • Front-clip harnesses. A 2024 PeerJ study walked 23 dogs on four types of kit. A front-connection harness cut pulling compared with a martingale collar, about as much as the prong collars did. That isn’t a case for prongs. More on those below.
  • The 2025 review. A review in the journal Animals looked at 21 studies and found there’s no one-size-fits-all. For pullers, non-tightening front-clip harnesses “appear to offer the best balance”. Back-clip Y-shaped harnesses suit flat-faced dogs or dogs that don’t pull, and flat collars are fine for dogs that don’t pull.
  • Stress. A Hartpury University study walked 30 dogs for 20 minutes each and found no significant difference in stress behaviours between collar and harness. So a harness isn’t magic. It’s about protecting the neck.

Which dog, which kit?

Puppies

Use a harness for walks while they learn not to pull, and a light flat collar for the tag. Puppies grow fast, so check the fit every couple of weeks. My new puppy checklist covers the rest of the kit.

Dogs that pull

A front-clip or two-clip harness plus training. The harness helps while you teach loose-lead walking, it doesn’t replace it. I like the Ruffwear Front Range harness. My how to stop your dog pulling on the lead post has the method, and best harness for dogs that pull compares options.

Calm, loose-lead walkers

If your dog genuinely walks without pulling, a flat collar on the lead is fine, and the 2025 review backs that. A harness is still kinder if they ever spot a cat and lunge.

Flat-faced breeds

Pugs, French bulldogs and similar dogs should walk on a harness, as the Royal Kennel Club advises. Talk to your vet if you’re worried about their breathing.

Escape artists and sighthounds

Some dogs are experts at backing out of a collar. A well-fitted harness they can’t slip is safer. If your dog has slipped a collar before, my dog GPS tracker guide is worth a read.

Reactive or lunging dogs

Every lunge on a collar lands on the neck, so walk them on a harness. If lunging is a regular thing, have a look at reactive dog training in Heywood.

Long-line recall work

Always clip a long line to a harness, never a collar. A dog hitting the end of 10 metres at speed is a lot of force. I use a 10m long line. For which line to buy, see the best long line for recall training, and my long line recall training post shows how.

The collar and ID tag law (UK)

The Control of Dogs Order 1992 says every dog “while in a highway or in a place of public resort shall wear a collar with the name and address of the owner inscribed on the collar or on a plate or badge attached to it.” There are exemptions, such as some working dogs and dogs registered with Guide Dogs.

  • Tag on the harness only? The Order says collar, and Dogs Trust, Battersea and the RSPCA all say collar with ID. A spare tag on the harness is a good backup, not a swap.
  • Microchipped? Wandsworth Council’s dogs and the law page says your dog “must still wear an identity tag even if it is microchipped”, and that the fine can be up to £5,000.
  • Phone number? The law asks for name and address. Adding a phone number makes sense so someone can ring you straight away.

Collars and kit I’d avoid on walks

  • Choke chains. PDSA says don’t use anything painful or that restricts movement, and names choke collars.
  • Prong collars. The RSPCA says they’re “designed to cause pain or discomfort”, and its vet notes they can injure the windpipe and thyroid glands. I’d never use one, whatever the 2024 study found about pulling.
  • Shock collars. Fitting one is an offence in Wales (PDSA). I’d never use one anywhere.
  • Harnesses across the shoulders or that tighten. Dogs Trust and the 2025 review both steer away from them.

Getting the fit right

  • Collar: snug, two fingers between the collar and the neck (Battersea).
  • Harness: you should fit a finger comfortably under the straps, it shouldn’t move about as your dog walks, and your dog shouldn’t be able to slip out (Dogs Trust). Look for a Y-shaped front that leaves the shoulders free.
  • Introduce it slowly with treats, a few seconds at a time, before the first walk.

Dark November walks: make the kit visible

The RSPCA says “a reflective collar or coat can help drivers, wildlife or other dog walkers see you when out walking in the dark countryside.” On winter evenings, a reflective harness or coat plus a clip-on light on the collar makes a real difference near roads.

Need a hand with walks?

If you’d rather someone else did the dark, wet ones, The Dog Geezer offers dog walking in Heywood and dog walking in Bury, plus adventure days. If pulling is the real problem, have a look at dog training in Heywood.

FAQ

Does my dog legally have to wear a collar if it wears a harness?

Yes, in public. The Control of Dogs Order 1992 says a collar with the owner’s name and address, and Dogs Trust says this applies even when walking in a harness.

Can I put the ID tag on the harness instead?

As a backup, yes. Instead of a collar, no: the law says collar.

Should a puppy wear a harness or a collar?

Both. Harness for walks while they learn, light collar for the tag. Check the fit often as they grow.

Will a harness stop my dog pulling?

It helps, but it doesn’t train your dog for you. See the pulling post.

All posts

Ready when your dog is

Ask James about your dog.

Tell James about your dog below. The first chat is free. Prefer to talk? Call James on 07305 634229 or email James.

We’ll use your details to reply to your enquiry. Read our privacy policy. An enquiry is not a confirmed booking.